Option pricesThe stock jumped my way and my option lost value
- What happens
- You buy an option before a big event. The stock moves the way you wanted and the option is worth less the next morning.
- Why it happens
- Options get expensive before a known event because a big move is possible. Once the news is out, that extra price leaves. Traders call it IV crush.
- Example
- A $105 call bought for $2.72 the day before earnings. The stock rises from $100 to $103, volatility falls from 40% to 22%, and the call is worth $1.83.
- How it affects your position
- A bought call or put can lose a large part of its value overnight, even with the direction right.
- How to avoid it
- Before buying into an event, compare the move you expect with the expected move the options already price in. Consider a spread, which is hurt less by the drop.
- What to do if it happens
- Judge the trade again from today's price. Holding and hoping the old price returns is a new bet, and time keeps passing.
The lesson behind it: Options around earningsOption pricesThe stock did not move and my option is down
- What happens
- You hold an option for a week. The stock is where it started and the option is worth less.
- Why it happens
- Part of an option's price is time. Each day that passes takes some of it away, and the daily amount grows as expiration gets close.
- Example
- A $105 call with 30 days left loses about $8 a day on one contract. With 7 days left it loses about $11 a day.
- How it affects your position
- A buyer pays for every day of waiting. A seller is paid for it.
- How to avoid it
- Buy more time than you think you need, and know the daily cost (theta) before you enter.
- What to do if it happens
- Ask whether the move you expected can still happen in the days that are left. If not, selling what remains is better than letting it run to zero.
The lesson behind it: The GreeksOption pricesI was down the moment I bought
- What happens
- Right after your order fills, the position shows a loss, before the stock has done anything.
- Why it happens
- You buy at the ask and the position is valued nearer the bid. The gap between the two is a cost you pay on the way in.
- Example
- An option quoted $2.60 bid, $2.80 ask. Buy at $2.80 and you could sell at $2.60: down $20 a contract at once.
- How it affects your position
- The wider the gap, the further the option has to move before you are even.
- How to avoid it
- Trade options with a narrow gap and plenty of contracts held. Use a limit order between the bid and the ask.
- What to do if it happens
- Nothing has gone wrong. Count the gap as part of the cost when you set your target.
The lesson behind it: Reading an option chainOption pricesThe stock rose and my cheap call still went to zero
- What happens
- You buy a low-priced call far above the stock price. The stock rises, but the call expires worthless.
- Why it happens
- At expiration a call is only worth something if the stock is above the strike. Up is not enough. It has to be up past the strike, and past the breakeven to make money.
- Example
- Stock at $100, $110 call bought for $1.44. The stock ends at $108, up 8%, and the call expires worth nothing.
- How it affects your position
- The whole amount paid is lost, even though you were right about the direction.
- How to avoid it
- Pick a strike whose breakeven sits inside the move you really expect.
- What to do if it happens
- If time is short and the strike is still far away, selling for what is left keeps part of the money.
The lesson behind it: Picking a strike and a dateOption pricesThe stock moved $1 and my option moved 30 cents
- What happens
- The stock makes a good move and the option changes by much less.
- Why it happens
- An option moves by its delta, not dollar for dollar. Out-of-the-money options have a small delta.
- Example
- A call with a 0.30 delta gains about 30 cents a share, or $30 a contract, when the stock rises $1.
- How it affects your position
- Small moves in the stock barely help a far out-of-the-money option, while time keeps taking value away.
- How to avoid it
- Check delta before you buy. If you want the option to track the stock closely, choose a strike nearer the stock price or in the money.
- What to do if it happens
- This is normal behaviour. Delta grows if the stock keeps moving toward the strike.
The lesson behind it: The GreeksOption pricesThe price on the chain was not the price I got
- What happens
- The chain shows a last price of $2.00. Your order fills at $2.60.
- Why it happens
- Last is the most recent trade, which on a quiet option can be from much earlier. The bid and the ask are where you can trade now.
- Example
- Last $2.00, bid $2.40, ask $2.60. A market order to buy fills at about $2.60.
- How it affects your position
- You pay more than you planned, or your limit order at the old price just sits there.
- How to avoid it
- Read the bid and the ask, never the last price. Use limit orders on options.
- What to do if it happens
- Work out your breakeven again from the price you really paid.
The lesson behind it: Reading an option chainExpirationI woke up owning 100 shares
- What happens
- You hold a call through expiration. On Monday the option is gone and 100 shares are in your account.
- Why it happens
- An option that is in the money at expiration, even by one cent, is normally exercised automatically.
- Example
- A $50 call, stock closes at $50.40. The call is exercised and you buy 100 shares for $5,000.
- How it affects your position
- You now carry a stock position, with its full risk, that you may not have the cash for.
- How to avoid it
- Close options you do not want exercised before the last day ends.
- What to do if it happens
- Decide if you want the shares. If not, sell them when the market opens. If the account is short of cash, call your broker first.
The lesson behind it: Expiration and assignmentExpirationI was assigned before expiration
- What happens
- You sold an option. Days before it expires, shares appear in (or leave) your account.
- Why it happens
- Options on stocks and ETFs can be exercised on any day. A buyer usually does it when the option is deep in the money with little time value left.
- Example
- You sold a $50 put. The stock falls to $42 and the buyer exercises. You buy 100 shares at $50.
- How it affects your position
- The option is gone and you hold the shares, or owe them, earlier than planned.
- How to avoid it
- Close or roll sold options once they are deep in the money. Index options such as SPX cannot be assigned early.
- What to do if it happens
- It is not a penalty. You received what the contract said. Decide whether to keep the shares or close them.
The lesson behind it: Expiration and assignmentExpirationMy option expired out of the money and I was still assigned
- What happens
- You sold an option that closed just out of the money on its last day. Over the weekend you learn you were assigned.
- Why it happens
- Buyers can still choose to exercise for a short while after the closing bell. If news moves the stock after hours, some of them do.
- Example
- You sold a $50 call. The stock closes at $49.90, then trades at $51 after hours on news. The buyer exercises.
- How it affects your position
- You are short or long 100 shares over the weekend without having planned for it.
- How to avoid it
- Buy back sold options that are near the strike on the last day, even for a few cents.
- What to do if it happens
- Close the share position when the market opens if you do not want it.
The lesson behind it: Expiration and assignmentExpirationOne leg of my spread was exercised and the other was not
- What happens
- You let a spread expire. One option was in the money and one was not, and now you hold shares.
- Why it happens
- Each option is settled by itself. If the stock ends between your two strikes, only one of them is exercised.
- Example
- A $100/$105 call spread, stock ends at $103. Your $100 call is exercised and you buy 100 shares. The $105 call expires.
- How it affects your position
- The spread's cap on risk is gone. You hold a full stock position over the weekend.
- How to avoid it
- Close spreads before the last day ends, as one order.
- What to do if it happens
- Close the shares when the market opens unless you want them.
The lesson behind it: Spreads: capping the riskExpirationMy broker sold my option on expiration day
- What happens
- On the last afternoon your option is sold without you placing an order.
- Why it happens
- If exercising the option would need more cash than the account has, many brokers close it for you before the bell.
- Example
- A $200 call in the money in a $3,000 account. Exercising would cost $20,000, so the broker sells the call in the last hours.
- How it affects your position
- You get whatever price the market gives at that moment, which may be worse than you could have had earlier.
- How to avoid it
- Close it yourself earlier on the last day, on your own terms.
- What to do if it happens
- Read the broker's notice. Their expiration-day rules are published, and they differ between brokers.
The lesson behind it: Expiration and assignmentOrdersMy market order filled far from the price I saw
- What happens
- You send a market order and the fill is well away from the quote on your screen.
- Why it happens
- A market order takes whatever is on offer. In the first minutes of the day, or in a thinly traded name, the offers can be far apart.
- Example
- A stock shows $20.00. At the open the nearest seller is at $20.45, and your market buy fills there.
- How it affects your position
- Your entry is worse than planned, so the distance to your stop and target has changed.
- How to avoid it
- Use limit orders, above all at the open, after hours and on options.
- What to do if it happens
- Work out your risk again from the real fill price. If the trade no longer fits your plan, it is fine to close it.
The lesson behind it: Order typesOrdersMy stop sold far below my stop price
- What happens
- Your stop is at $48. The stock opens at $44 and your shares are sold near $44.
- Why it happens
- A stop order becomes a market order once the price is reached. If the stock jumps past your price overnight, the next available price is the fill.
- Example
- Bad news after the close. The stock ends the day at $50 and opens at $44. A stop at $48 fills at about $44.
- How it affects your position
- The loss is larger than the one you sized the trade for.
- How to avoid it
- Size positions so a gap hurts but does not wreck the account. Be careful holding through earnings and other scheduled news.
- What to do if it happens
- Accept the fill and record it. A stop-limit order would not have sold at all, and you would still hold a falling stock.
The lesson behind it: Order typesOrdersThe price touched my limit and I did not get filled
- What happens
- The chart shows the price reached your limit, but your order is still open.
- Why it happens
- Orders at the same price are filled in the order they arrived. The price can trade at your limit and move away before your turn comes.
- Example
- You bid $25.00. A few hundred shares trade at $25.00, all from orders ahead of yours, then the price lifts.
- How it affects your position
- You are not in the trade you thought you had.
- How to avoid it
- If getting filled matters more than the last cent, set the limit slightly through the price you want.
- What to do if it happens
- Check your open orders before assuming you have a position. Then decide whether the trade still makes sense at the new price.
The lesson behind it: Order typesOrdersOnly part of my order filled
- What happens
- You ordered 500 shares and received 120. The rest is still waiting.
- Why it happens
- There were not enough shares or contracts on offer at your price to fill the whole order.
- Example
- A limit to buy 10 option contracts at $2.50. Three trade at $2.50 and the ask moves to $2.60.
- How it affects your position
- Your position is smaller than planned, and the unfilled part can still fill later, when you may no longer want it.
- How to avoid it
- Trade names with enough volume for your size, and keep an eye on what is still open.
- What to do if it happens
- Cancel the remainder if the setup has changed. Set your stop for the size you really hold.
The lesson behind it: Order typesYour accountMy account was restricted after a few day trades
- What happens
- After several trades opened and closed on the same day, the broker blocks new day trades.
- Why it happens
- US brokers limit day trading in small margin accounts. The long-standing rule allows three day trades in five business days below a $25,000 balance. Check your broker's current rule.
- Example
- Four round trips in one week in a $6,000 margin account. The fourth flags the account.
- How it affects your position
- You may be unable to close and reopen positions the same day for a period, or be asked to add money.
- How to avoid it
- Count your day trades. Hold trades overnight, or use a cash account, where the limit works differently.
- What to do if it happens
- Read the broker's notice and call them. Many brokers will clear a first flag once.
Your accountI sold a stock and could not use the money
- What happens
- In a cash account you sell shares, then get a warning when you try to trade again with the same money.
- Why it happens
- A sale takes one business day to settle. Buying with unsettled money and selling that new position before the money settles breaks the rules.
- Example
- Sell stock A on Monday, buy stock B with that money, sell B on Monday too. The money from A had not settled yet.
- How it affects your position
- Repeat it and the broker can restrict the account to settled cash only for 90 days.
- How to avoid it
- In a cash account, trade with settled cash or hold the new position until the next day.
- What to do if it happens
- One warning does no harm. Check the settled cash figure before each trade from then on.
Your accountMy broker sold my shares without asking
- What happens
- Positions bought with borrowed money fall, and the broker sells some of them.
- Why it happens
- A margin account must keep a minimum share of its own money. If losses push it below that line, the broker can sell positions to restore it, with or without calling first.
- Example
- $10,000 of your money and $10,000 borrowed in one stock. The stock drops 40%. Your share is now $2,000 of $12,000, under the minimum.
- How it affects your position
- Shares are sold at the low, the loss is locked in, and you do not choose which positions go.
- How to avoid it
- Borrow less than the account allows, or not at all. Use stops and keep some cash free.
- What to do if it happens
- Add money or reduce positions yourself right away, so the choice of what to sell stays yours.
Your accountTrading in my stock stopped
- What happens
- Orders in one stock stop filling for minutes, sometimes longer. The quote is frozen.
- Why it happens
- Exchanges pause a stock after a very fast move or ahead of major news, so everyone can see the information before trading starts again.
- Example
- A small stock jumps 15% in two minutes. It is paused for five minutes and can reopen at a very different price.
- How it affects your position
- You cannot get in or out during the pause, and stops do not protect you from the reopening price.
- How to avoid it
- Keep size small in fast, thinly traded stocks, where pauses are most common.
- What to do if it happens
- Wait for the reopen. Cancel resting market orders if you do not want whatever price comes next.
FuturesMy futures chart jumped on roll day
- What happens
- On one day the chart of your futures product jumps by dozens of points with no news.
- Why it happens
- The chart switched from the expiring contract to the next one. They are different contracts and trade at different prices.
- Example
- The December contract is at 6,000 and the March contract at 6,055. A chart that joins them shows a 55 point jump.
- How it affects your position
- Nothing was made or lost. Levels you drew on the old contract now sit in the wrong place.
- How to avoid it
- Know the roll date for your product and use a chart that adjusts for it.
- What to do if it happens
- Check which contract month your platform is showing, and redraw your levels on the new one.
The lesson behind it: Expiration months and rollingFuturesMy futures position was closed near the end of the day
- What happens
- Shortly before the session ends, the broker closes your position without an order from you.
- Why it happens
- You were trading on the lower day margin. Holding overnight needs the full margin, and the account did not have it.
- Example
- Two MES held on $100 of day margin each in a $1,500 account. Overnight margin is $2,500 a contract, so the broker closes both before the cut-off.
- How it affects your position
- You are out at whatever the price is at that moment, sometimes with a fee.
- How to avoid it
- Know your broker's cut-off time and the overnight margin. Close positions yourself before it.
- What to do if it happens
- Read the notice, then put the cut-off time where you can see it every day.
The lesson behind it: Margin and leverageFuturesI lost more than I had in my futures account
- What happens
- After a sharp move your balance is negative. The broker asks you to pay the difference.
- Why it happens
- A futures position is many times larger than the deposit behind it. A fast move or a gap can lose more than the deposit before anyone can act.
- Example
- A $3,000 account holding two ES contracts. A 40 point gap against the position is a $4,000 loss.
- How it affects your position
- The account is at minus $1,000, and that amount is a debt.
- How to avoid it
- Trade micros, keep spare cash well above the margin, and stay out through major scheduled news.
- What to do if it happens
- Contact the broker the same day. The debt does not go away, and brokers do arrange payment.
The lesson behind it: Margin and leverageFuturesMy futures statement shows a different profit than my screen
- What happens
- The daily statement shows a slightly different result from what the platform showed at the close.
- Why it happens
- Accounts are marked to the exchange's settlement price, which is worked out from trading around the close. It is not the last trade.
- Example
- The last trade you saw was 6,010.00. The settlement price was 6,009.25. On one ES that is $37.50.
- How it affects your position
- The day-to-day split of your profit shifts a little. The total over the life of the trade is the same.
- How to avoid it
- There is nothing to avoid. Expect the two numbers to differ.
- What to do if it happens
- Compare the totals once the trade is closed. They match.
The lesson behind it: How futures settleTaxesMy loss did not count on my taxes
- What happens
- Your broker's tax form marks a loss as disallowed, and your taxable gain is higher than what you made.
- Why it happens
- You sold at a loss and bought the same stock back within 30 days. US rules postpone that loss by adding it to the cost of the new shares.
- Example
- Sell at a $500 loss on Monday and buy back on Wednesday. The $500 is not deducted now. The new shares cost $500 more on paper.
- How it affects your position
- In a year of trading the same names, many losses can be pushed out, and the tax bill can surprise you.
- How to avoid it
- Wait 31 days before buying back, or accept the rule and plan for it. It applies across all of your accounts.
- What to do if it happens
- Keep the form and take it to a tax professional. The loss usually counts once the new shares are sold for good.
The lesson behind it: Taxes: a short US overview